Ten Years after the Twin Towers Collapse, Gaza Has Something to Say.

Gaza 08/09

Twin Towers 2001

Being Muslim nowadays is difficult. But being both Gazan and Muslim can be of a disastrous impact. As many here see it, Islamophobia is a term invented by racist groups whose purpose is to point an accusation finger at a certain people –Muslims- each time an “act of terrorism” strikes the world. This is an odd generalization that is simply not true.

“The war on terror” that manifested itself in the uncurbed words of George W. Bush –former US president- immediately following the September 11th attacks on New York’s Twin Towers did not spare Gaza.

With Hamas taking control over the Strip in 2007, biased media outlets began waging propaganda hurricanes to influence the world see Gaza a zone of terror where criminal armed gangs seek to wipe Israel off the map. They also took advantage of the Sept. 11th attacks by concocting stories about purported collaboration between Hamas and al-Qaeda. To the west, both Hamas and al-Qaeda pose danger to humankind. Khaled Meshaal, a prominent Hamas political leader, said in an interview done in Syria for US public TV that Hamas is a resistance group that fights Israeli colonization only as opposed to al-Qaeda that is involved in international terrorism.

Backed by the US, in late 2008, the war on Gaza was launched. Twenty two days of relentless aggression against a mostly-civilian population was justified as necessary operation to uproot terrorist infrastructure throbbing through this densely populated area.

In Gaza, Islamophobia features itself through motherless and childless nights many kids and mothers have to swallow. Since Israel proclaimed Gaza a den where terrorists need to be cleansed, hundreds – not to exaggerate- of such innocent lives have been claimed.

One could lean into his window in the morning to look out on an impoverished refugee camp or smear his morning coffee when inhaling sewage-drenched air. It is always obvious that Israel has suspected every standing figure of hiding terrorists no matter how shapeless or worn out these figures seem to be. And more, in disregard to how huge the banners reading “School” or “playground” for both schools and playgrounds are equally suspected whatsoever.

Mohammad Suleiman, 21 years old Gazan blogger thought of the reasons behind this Islamophobia: “If we want to talk about the reasons, of course they are many: some have to do with Zionist agenda and securing the state of Israel against not all Palestinians but all Arabs and Muslims”. But he is optimistic: “I think there is a growing awareness now in Europe in regard to this although Islamophobia reached astonishing levels in the US due to the role of AIPAC and other Zionist groups.”

The truth, although surprising, is that the majority of Gazans, if not all of them, are trying to find solutions where Palestinians and Israelis can live in peace and harmony together.  While one part hopes to fulfill this dream by opting for a Two-State solution, the other supports One State. I, the writer, have lived in Gaza all my life, and it never happened that I encountered someone who wants to “wipe Israel off the map”. Even if such minority exists, it’s worth mentioning that in Israel itself, there are people who wish to wipe Palestine off the map.

Here is what Eman Sourani, 22 years old, and a One-Stator thinks: “The issue isn’t about getting rid of people but of Apartheid. We need to end the Israeli Apartheid that is based on Zionism”.

A few weeks ago, in a summer camp in Norway, dozens of young Norwegians were sprayed with bullets to end lives of over seventy and wound several others. International press and social media suddenly began blabbering about Muslim perpetrators who were labeled -as usual- as “terrorists”. A few days later, the perpetrator turned out to be just an “extremist”. Indeed, to describe a Norwegian, lighter term becomes a necessity.

This incident and this manipulation of language brought back the pictures of the September 11thattacks. In Gaza, young bloggers began raising many questions.

“If the person who killed 70+ people in Norway was a Muslim, the Press would have declared him as terrorist. For now though, he is just an ‘Assailant ‘, ‘Attacker’ (Reuters), ‘Gunman’ (BBC, CNN & Al Jazeera). Looks like ‘Terrorist ‘ is a name reserved for Muslims? The US Dept of State calls it an ‘Act of Violence’, not an ‘Act of Terrorism’”. Samah Saleh, 22, updated her Facebook status.

Samah is a Muslim, but she’s not a terrorist. She’s a medical-school student and one example of thousands of successful young Muslims in Gaza.  Actually, thousands of students graduate from Gaza-based universities every year.

Extremists and terrorists exist within every community regardless of their sects, religions and beliefs. Criminals cannot represent every individual and religion in a given society, but rather the influences that surrounded them as they grew up. Evidently, this singling-out of a people and unreasonably putting them in an isolated category is nothing but an act of racial discrimination.

Shaimaa al-Waheidi, 23, a recent graduate argues that there is lack of understanding in regard to religions especially Islam: “USA and everyone should understand that all religions are innocent from the people’s crimes. For me, as a Palestinian citizen, I feel very sorry for the families of September 11th victims”.

“These attacks insulted us and insulted our religion. Our religion is a religion of peace and we are against these attacks.” Agreed Lara Abu-Ramadan, 19, a writer of Arabic prose. “After the attacks on the World Trade Center, Muslims were treated like terrorists in Europe. Before I traveled to France this year, I had fears that people might be offensive to my Hijab, but they were better than I had imagined despite some scornful looks I received. Sometimes these looks made me feel weird; it hurts being treated this way” she described.

But have the attacks affected the lives of the young people of Gaza?

Sahimaa and Mohammad, both mentioned earlier, had something to say: “I think the September 11th attacks haven’t really affected my life as a Muslim because I do believe that the USA government had already shaped its constant vision about Islam before the attacks happened” said Shaimaa.  Mohammad’s answer was a bit different: “They might affect me in person, but I think I can help fight back these prejudices and misrepresentations”.

The current assaults on Gaza, unlike what took place on September 11th 2001, are not being covered by Western media.  Three children among six civilians were massacred and yet nothing has been reported. These children killed and women injured are not different from women and children killed and injured on Sept.11th. In either case, the victims are non-combatant civilians and more importantly, not terrorists. Western media, let’s face it, reports discriminately. Blind eyes and deaf ears are always turned toward those who seem to be less important in the eyes of outwitting politicians whose game of power determines victims and murderers in total disregard to the truth.

21 Responses to “Ten Years after the Twin Towers Collapse, Gaza Has Something to Say.”

  1. Ahmed Adel Says:

    Let me disagree with you in one point: Israel has no right to exist, because they built their state on Palestinian Lands, with the aim of making a “Jewish” state. This is against all laws and norms :)

  2. BelalDarkness Says:

    @Ahmed: there are alot of empty places in USA that can be used to build a new israeli state , they just have to leave our land and pay a visit to their allies , but to wibe a state off the map means killing and massacring all people in it , which noone would agree with.
    Rana : I couldn’t agree more with this my terrorist sister :D

  3. Trudy Says:

    Rana – you write beautifully. Please clarify – do you consider `wiping Israel off the map’ killing all Israelis or just Israel no longer existing?You say no one advocates `wiping Israel off the map’ when many in the region would propose that Israel did not exist. Also weapons have been stored in mosques and schools. Israelis and Palestinians both have a right to live in peace and security.

  4. Ahmed Adel Says:

    @Belal: Well, I think we agree on the same point. Israeli citizens can go back to their origins, whether from Europe or America. But to say that Israel has the right to exist means that we should forget about history. How did “Israel” appear on the map? Wasn’t it by “killing and massacring” the people of Palestine? Why should we be advocates of human rights and remember that they are human beings while they NEVER thought of it? If you were a refugee, would you accept living in another country because it is “inhuman” to wipe Israel off the map? Well, THEY did wipe Palestine off the map, didn’t they?

  5. Rana Baker Says:

    @Ahmed, thank you for your comment. The Israelis are people and all people have the right to exist. However, the important point about this, is how a people exercise this right. In terms of Israel, they ethnically cleanse Palestinian villages, towns and cities and replace them by Jews throughout a system of Apartheid and racial discrimination.

    @Trudy, wiping Israel off the map (which no one advocates) refers to another Holocaust or any such horrific genocide against Israeli Jews. Actually, Palestinians and Israelis both had lived in peace and harmony before the “state of Israel” was established in 1948 on ethnically cleansed Palestinian villages. Israel did not exist as a state before its creation in 1948. Jews, however, were welcomed in Palestine by Palestinians as immigrants following Hitler’s Holocaust. This is a stark fact. As for mosques and schools, I’m afraid I will have to disagree with you. This bit is inaccurate. Considering Operation Cast Lead that took place in winter 08/09, Israel had bombed hundreds of civilians who took refuge in UNRWA schools. UNRWA could not have allowed arms to enter its schools at all levels. Regarding mosques, a nearby one was leveled as a result of suspecting a “tunnel” through which arms go into and out of the mosque. I visited that mosque myself, and there was not a single indication of any kind of tunnels. I hope I answered your question as should be done. Thanks for your comment and you’re always welcome to post your questions/thoughts here.

  6. Ahmed Adel Says:

    @Rana: You know how much I praise your mind and respect your opinions. I was just afraid that Palestinians would agree on a “half” solution, just because this is the least they could dream of — as if it is أضعف الإيمان to just live in peace with Israel. Believe me, this cannot be done. Can you think of some people going to the Egyptian desert for example, and announcing from now on that this is the “State of XYZ”? And then they would start killing their neighbours to get more lands … and after 60 or 70 years, they would depend on the weakness of our memories and the weakness of our country to say: Okay, we can allow you to live in peace with us! Why, it is OUR LAND, and YOU CAME JUST LIKE THAT!
    In my opinion there are two possible solutions: Either the Israelis go back to their origins, or accept to live as Palestinian citizens within the State of PALESTINE!! :)

  7. Rana Baker Says:

    Ahmed, that is exactly what I’m saying here; it is that the Israelis are welcome to live in Palestine as equal citizens not as occupiers and conquerors. I, a Palestinian, do not recognize half solutions. It is either fulfillment of all basic rights (The right to return, end of occupation and the dismantling of the Apartheid wall and the right to full equality) or resistance by all means. No compromises can ever be offered over these in my name.

  8. Ahmed Adel Says:

    I have to say this in Arabic ya Rana! No, in Egyptian Arabic:
    الله عليكى! هوّ ده الكلام
    Yes, this makes me sure that victory is ours, since our generations are well aware of the issue and are not deceived by the western false propaganda :) .
    God bless you!

  9. Rana Baker Says:

    I love Egyptian Arabic, you have no idea! Thanks Ahmed. I’m proud of Egypt, and love Egypt. God bless you too and there is no such a way through which Western propaganda can make its way to our minds. My eyes are a better witness.

  10. Ahmed Adel Says:

    I love Palestine and I am proud of being an Arab!
    Thank you :)

  11. Trudy Says:

    Dear Rana
    Thank you for welcoming me to your blog. However, you sadden me so much. You are such a bright and articulate young lady, yet you yearn for the eradication of Israel. The reality is that the outcome you suggest of one state, majority Arab. would be a disaster for Israeli Jews. It will not happen. The only way forward for Palestinians to have a better life is to live in peace with your neighbour. `Resistance by all means’ has created the dire situation you are in today where Israeli security overrides everything else. Bright and modern young people like yourself, who can communicate so effectively with the rest of the world, should be looking for a brighter future, not yet more war and unrealistic expectations. Also, do not be naive about the way Hamas fights which puts you and your families in so much danger. I will not pollute your blog with a dissenting voice – that is not fair on you – and I wish you and your family a wonderful future living in peace with Israel. Rana – you could use your voice and your beautiful writing to lead the way..
    Shalom and Salaam
    Trudy

  12. Rana Baker Says:

    Thank you again, Trudy, for letting me know how misinformed you are regarding many important matters.

    First, since you’re not Palestinian, I would like you to pay some attention to the fact that only Palestinians can decide and choose what is better for themselves not you or anyone else.

    You may want to know that Hamas does not put me in danger when they fire rockets at tanks or Israeli soldiers. It’s lame to expect Palestinians to remain silent while Israel kills their children and imposes illegal siege on a mostly-civilian population.

    As for a one state, I feel sorry your media is consistently succeeding in hiding the truth away from you. Your fear of an Arab majority and eradication is justified. Your ancestors had been exposed to the horrific Shoa and horrendous concentration camps. I, however, cannot find a justification for establishing a system of Apartheid on a land that was ethnically cleansed from its original Palestinian people in 1948. Contrary to what you had been told, the one state means that Palestine belongs to all of those who live in it. The exact South African doctrine suggested by Nilson Mandella in the 1950s specifically in the Freedom Charter: “South Africa belongs to all of those who live in it.” When the Whites eventually realized that Apartheid only results in massacres, endless wars and economic losses, they listened to Mandela who clung to his word. A two-state solution, with illegal settlements snaking through the West Bank, checkpoints separating kids from their schools, Jewish-only roads and an Apartheid wall, succeeds in one thing: establishing Palestinian Banustans on less than 22% of historic Palestine. You may also want to remember Netenyahu’s speech at AIPAC when he declared the 1967 lines as indefensible. A man like Netenyahu, does not want peace. He’s eager to create “Greater Israel” on wreckage of demolished houses and displaced civilians.

    Only a One-State solution, gurantees every one in the state equal rights and freedom.

  13. Ahmed Adel Says:

    @Rana: Is there a LIKE button here? No, an ADORE button! All I have to do is show my favourite quotes!
    “First, since you’re not Palestinian, I would like you to pay some attention to the fact that only Palestinians can decide and choose what is better for themselves not you or anyone else.”
    جامده قوى الدخله دى :D
    “A two-state solution, with illegal settlements snaking through the West Bank, checkpoints separating kids from their schools, Jewish-only roads and an Apartheid wall, succeeds in one thing: establishing Palestinian Banustans on less than 22% of historic Palestine.”
    In fact, the whole reply is a “favourite quote”.
    You replied logically and politely, proving your point with true evidence from history. It seems that you are well aware of the history of the nations fighting for their independence and freedom. Perhaps it is your studies that made you thus :) .
    ربنا يحميكى ويخليكى لأهلك ويبعد عنك أى شر

    @Trudy: Would you please check this photo to know what we are talking about :) ?

    photo/1/large

    Thanks in advance :)

  14. Rana Baker Says:

    I’d like to thank you again, Ahmad, for your kind words. I will work harder to fully deserve them. I’m very pleased you follow my twitter and blog updates. Egypt has inspired us, the Palestinians, a lot. Rabna ykhaleek :)

  15. yolandaas Says:

    Great post! I’m doing a presentation in college about Islamophobia.. you give some great thoughts and facts! I totally agree. Especially about the Norway situation, I pointed this out on my fb aswell.

  16. Rana Baker Says:

    Thank you Yolandaas. I’m very pleased you liked the post and hope your presentation will go well. Please keep visiting my blog.

    Very Best,
    Rana

  17. Lina Hasayen Says:

    Today I heard about you on twitter and decided to check out your blog. How amazed and shocked I am from how smart and intellectual you are! I’m am amazed at your beautifully written stories and just have to read the next one after the other. I am a Palestinian living in Australia and am only 15 but amazingly can relate to your opinions. As I go to a multicultural school which mostly contains Arabs(yay lucky me!) I still feel lost and “unaccepted” around them. And my teachers assume that i have suiciding parents, live in gaza with no home and have come here for a “better” life. And when I try to express and tell my opinions about Palestine and my culture they somehow have some backup plan to try to step on me or make me feel that i am the wrong. But try to say it in a “nice and simple way” to hide the fact that they are trying to insult and offend me! I Know that the teachers dislike me but hide it ofcourse. Anyways your blog is very touching and from now on I will always be following you twitter. Ahmed I love Egypt! And am dieting to go visit it sometime. I love the culture, the music, even the movies and shows! Haha nd don’t forget the people of Egypt are VERY GOOD LOOKING! Thanks Rama for the blog your doing a great job ;)

    • Ahmed Adel Says:

      @ Lina:
      I was going to reply to you when suddenly I found you mentioning me already :D ! Wow, I liked the way you expressed yourself. Very good for on of your age :) .
      Try to show them that an Arab is a successful person. You will be a message walking on two legs. I am a teacher and I really know how we appreciate excellent students, even if they are from another country or so. Unless they are biased, they will appreciate you very well.
      Do you believe Egyptians are good looking? What about Palestinains and Syrians then? :D Come on!!

  18. Lina Hasayen Says:

    Haha thanks ;) a teacher! Good on you I swear the people here in Melbourne think that Arabs can’t do shit! They think that Arab girls drop out of school, get married at 15, have 10 kids and become housewives for the rest of their lives! their so stereotypical :O I saw on your twitter that you in Cairo! Your English is great! Did you live and study outside and then moved to Egypt? I swear if you tell me that you lived in Egypt your whole life I will be shocked!!! Your English is perfect!

    • Ahmed Adel Says:

      LOL ya Lina! I am a teacher of English language, so my English should be excellent :) ! I have never travelled abroad, but I read a lot. Perhaps that is why my English got improved.

      You say Palestinian boys are good-looking? Then what shall we say about the young ladies? Far beyond description!

      Sorry ya Rana for talking aside here :$! I promise you I won’t do it again. Lina, let’s talk on Twitter or sth :)

  19. Lina Hasayen Says:

    Haha palestinains and Syrians are pretty good looking too! Went to Palestine last summer with my family and died from how good-looking the guys were! I swear I can’t wait to go back!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 4,618 other followers