This article was also published on The Electronic Intifada and The Great Book Robbery which I highly recommend you to visit.

Gaza – A church and a mosque that have shared a wall for hundreds of years. Photo Credit: Ruqaya Izzidien
We Palestinians have nothing to cherish more than our roots and ancestral identity. To us, olive trees and the shade in which our grandparents rested or lovers used to secretly meet weave together sweet pre-dispossession memories.
My grandmother’s depleted voice can’t but play and replay the same ecstatic melodies of a womanhood (before 1967) spent between Gaza and Jerusalem, or actually, between Gaza and an Israeli officer and from there to Jerusalem. She would repeat to me again and again how smoothly (compared to now) she and her Jerusalemite relatives could visit each other. According to her, the most difficult part was to find a carriage.
I would nod my head, sip my tea, and contemplate her face. It is really difficult to imagine that the young adventurous woman who could “smoothly” go to and enjoy Jerusalem is the same one as my wrinkled grandmother. Later, I would be struck by the fact that she is eight decades old. Eight decades! Older than the Nakba? Yes.
One of my grandmother’s clearest memories of the few years prior to the Nakba is one of a British officer who stood before a Palestinian crowd that happened to include my grandmother. According to her, everybody was there to celebrate the inauguration of a new British-established school in Gaza.
My grandmother narrates: “Can you see me, Rana? I can see the officer in front of eyes now. I remember him yelling and cheering until he uttered these words: ‘Today we are your guests, but tomorrow you will be ours.’” A deep breath and she continues: “we were too naïve to fathom the demon snoring in his speech.”
My grandmother, therefore, is a living evidence of the irrefutable fact that Palestinians had forged lives in Palestine until Zionist gangs, like the Hagana, Irgun and the Stern Gang, to name a few, viciously drove Palestinians out of their lands.
They destroyed our villages, but not our heritage
In our schools and families, we are raised to identify ourselves with our heritage and the villages or towns from which we originally descend.
It is neither surprising nor is it phenomenal when a seven-year-old boy knows exactly which Palestinian village or town is his home of origin and offers a brief but accurate description of his grandfather’s stolen or destroyed house, even if he’s never been allowed to visit himself.
Our heritage is not only the black or red checkered kufiyyeh scarf and the traditional embroidered dress; it is a scent wafting carried on the breeze from olive groves, vines and figs. Alas, everything was and continues to be subject to Israel’s relentless attempts to loot a deep-rooted Palestinian culture.
To us, especially the young, books are our solace from a life of turbulence and uncertainty. We are more attached to the characters of some novel than to the bombs falling down from the sky. Yet, Israel doesn’t allow that. Every single book I have was smuggled to me by one of my non-Palestinian friends who travel a lot.
Furthermore, more than 6,000 Palestinian books are now languishing on the shelves of Israel’s National Library indexed with the label AP or “Absentee Property.” Those “absentees” are Palestinian refugees whose dream and right to return have been denied for so long.
Israel, however, can never loot a culture of nonviolence and stone-throwing. Frankly speaking, without massacring and dispossessing tens of thousands of Palestinians, Israel could have never come to existence in the first place.
It is almost impossible to imagine a decked-out Israeli soldier picking up a stone to hurl it at Palestinian protestors in Nabi Saleh or Beit Hanoun in the West Bank or Gaza, respectively. On the same note, it cannot be possibly pictured that Palestinian protestors would riddle Israeli “guards” with rubber bullets, tear gas or live ammunition.
Heritage of tolerance
Walking through the roads of Palestine attests to a history of religious tolerance. With Christmas coming soon, Palestinian florists and gift shops, mostly owned by Muslims, are adorned with Christmas trees, Santa Claus costumes and glowing lights. Here, Muslims and Christians are neighbors and friends. Every Christmas, Muslims visit their Christian neighbors and offer warm hugs and outings together.
I was educated in a Christian school; I clearly remember my Christian classmates fasting during Ramadan with us or at least, avoiding eating in front of us. Christians here, despite being a minority, celebrate Eid with us. They even go get new outfits every Eid as is the Muslim custom.
Even the construction testifies to warm relations and deep respect. In the old part of Gaza, you will find a Orthodox church that shares a wall with an ancient Turkish mosque. Both the church and the mosque have stood there for hundreds of years.
Prior to the Nakba, the above situation applied to relations with Jews; but when the Israeli state was established on 15 May 1948 and declared a “Jewish-state,” Jews were separated from Muslims and Christians. Even those Jews who were not affiliated with the Zionist movement had to be separated.
Palestinians do not come from Mars, but we are constantly alienated and our demands swept off to corners like dust.
I lost faith in the so-called “international community” a long time ago. I don’t even know whether I have ever had any sort of trust in it.
None of the UN resolutions that could have brought us fragments of justice have ever been implemented. The 1947 UN resolution on the partition of Palestine (181), however, was upheld and implemented. This resolution served nobody but the Zionist movement and therefore the perpetuation of our misery.
The cultural war Israel has fueled is aimed at de-Palestinianizing the Palestinians and those who choose to stand on the right side of history. This is why the Palestinian Campaign for the Academic and Cultural Boycott of Israel (PACBI) exists. Israel has cultural obligations to meet and must be pressured into complying with them. Until it does, the campaign will not stop.
December 8, 2011 at 2:55 pm |
The injustice of this is heartbreaking. The oppressed became the oppressors with barely a breath. I hope, inshallah, one day the world will accept what you have known your whole life. Standing with you in solidarity and praying for the end of this misery…..
December 9, 2011 at 9:26 pm |
Stop teaching your children what towns and villages their ancestors came from. What a pointless exercise. Look forward, not back. 800,000 Jews were driven from their homes in Arab lands – do you think they harp on about it all the time? They get on with their lives and so should the Palestinians. And before you start on about how you can’t get on with your lives with the blockade etc, just think what would happen if you stopped fighting and moved on.
December 10, 2011 at 1:40 pm |
JaneB : I wonder then what heritage should we teach them “hi kids , you came from nowhere and have no home and should accept that”
every nation teaches it’s kids i’s sorrows and achievements , their home , their history , their heritage , will you also deny us even from this??
I know that I want my share of my familly’s house in the destroyed village of “Qubaiba” , and I know that I have the right to demand it and will teach my kids about their stolen prperties when they can undesrstand , just like you would teach your kds about your religion , freedom , Social structure , and heritage.
December 10, 2011 at 2:54 pm |
Hey Bela – definitely have not been taught to long for my grandparents homes in Egypt and Iraq. Know my history but am not taught to yearn for what has been stolen from us. Do not think it is healthy. Definitely good to know where you came from but longing to have it back leaves people in a state of unrealistic expectations. We had a large very prosperous factory in Egypt,. Were given 24 hours to leave. Do I have the right to demand it back? How many people around the world lost homes and property in the 30s and 40 s – literally millions and millions. How many yearn to get it all back and what sort of world would ot be if we all took up arms to get back what our families had then?
December 10, 2011 at 3:45 pm |
you want us to forget our Nakba , yet you stil cry about your Holocoast , doesn’t sound really good does it?
your people are still stealing our lands and houses in the present day with your colonial settlements expansion , you still take billions of dollars from Germany for a leader they had even before our rights you want us to forget , you still imprison thousands and call us terrorists for fighting for our rights while you dont hesitate shooting Phosphorus bombs on children , burning them slowly and giving them -Hell on Earth- , no JaneB , I wont forget my home.
December 10, 2011 at 4:37 pm |
And you take more aid than the whole of Africa – who is talking about money? Let the world follow the example of the Palestinians. Lets all go after what we lost two generations ago. I shall spread the word to India and Pakistan – far more people were displaced than in Palestine. And then we can spread it all over Europe. Lets all take up arms to recover what we lost. What a ghastly world you are proposing if we do it the Palestinian way. And I did not tell you to forget your naqba – I told you to stop yearning after what you lost. Jews will always remember the holocaust but do not yearn to return to those properties. And I personally believe in reparations for Palestinians but no right of return
December 12, 2011 at 10:37 pm |
we barely take anything compared to Funds israel recieve , and Israel doesnt even need these funds as it have a strong economy of it’s own.
and you still measure with double standards , “Zionists” and not jews are those whome I talk about , there are jews against the state of israel , and others pro-Palestine etc… so I only talk of those who came from all over the world to take my land by force.
you dont want to get back to your homes but you demand unstopable compensations for what happened two or even three generations ago ? fine , and we dont want compensations , but we want our homes back , we want our holy places back , we want to end our shatterness around a world that refer to us as “Terrorists” due to Israeli-American war on terrorism that spread falseness about all arabs as terrorists.
Pakistan and india have their wars already over Kashmir region , even if the two countries were divided -formally to avoid bloodshed – with both the Great Hindu leader Ghandi , and The great muslim Leader Jawaher Lal nehro Approval , not by people who came from all the world to set a country on a stolen land , there are alot of freedom fighter movements around the world , we as Palestinians can barely support our self in internal policy matters , rather than support or antagonize such Guerilla groups.
and you completely ignore the fact that Land-stealing proccess never stopped , it started since 1800′s , and is continued untill today , and the 22% of historical Palestine we were promissed to establish our country on in Oslo records is shrinking daily due to continuess stealing proccess , and those thieves who steal it “Settlers” would be imprisoned in any law abiding country due to their continous harrasment , attacking , beating up , bullying to their local arab neighbours.
we wont abandon our right of return just because you dont see the point of it , history isn’t something you just forget , and justisce shall be achieved sooner or later.
December 18, 2011 at 9:07 pm
Bela – we will never agree and you are entitled to your opinions. I do not feel you have been given any balance in your education so here are a few facts for you…
A. We have had no compensation from Arab countries when 800,000 Jews were expelled. Jews from Arab lands are always forgotten.
B. Your holy places were built on top of ours. Judaism pre dates Islam so they are currently with their rightful owner.
C. There is no ideology more expansionist and colonialist than Islam
D. Settlers should be imprisoned when they commit criminal acts
At least we are agreed on this one.
January 11, 2012 at 7:39 pm |
first of all I am Belal , not Bela.
as for you accusation about my education , I’ll spare the useless debate about it and just head to your points.
A- french-british controlled governments had no power upon their people more than those who occupy them , you could demand them for compensation tho still you didnt , as for real compensation it’s what you get annually from Germany , or perhaps you forgot that or you have “unballanced education etc….”
B- your kingdom of israel were built on our land , Cannanites pre dates hebrews in matter of ownershi to this land , making the descenders of cannanites -Palestinians- the rightfull owners.
C- Islam is a religion , and when theocratics come to power they give their religion their bloody rebutation , there is no religion that have no blood on it’s hands , I am an ex-atheist myself , currently asecular muslim completely against theocracy whether it is muslim brotherhood – salfists – zionism – crusaders etc…. still I am a muslim and I hold no grudge against any religion I dont care if you are a stanist and if I marry a hindu and our kids become jews and chrisytians and bhuddists , but I can tell you have grugge against Islam , making me a better person.
D- without settlers I’m sure israel can decrease international critics at great level. and it will decrease the urge for resistance for us making a great boost to peace.
I gota go eat now , sorry if I didnt revise this comment for grammatical mistakes.
January 13, 2012 at 4:17 pm |
My apologies Belal for getting your name wrong and I would just like to clarify I was not commenting on your general education, just your education about the Jews that were ethnically cleansed from Arab countries with no compensation. Our story is always forgotten. You seem to be extremely intelligent.
Whether Muslims were the original Cannanites is extremely dubious. If you go back that far you could say it was the Jewish G-d who created Adam and Eve. I was talking about Jewish holy sites and Muslim holy sites and the Jewish ones without doubt pre date the Muslim ones,
I have no grudge against Islam as a religion – all are entitled to their beliefs – I only object when people want to destroy me. I have no idea whether you are a better person and I certainly would never think I was better than you. Hope you enjoyed your dinner. Has been good chatting. Our perspectives and backgrounds are so different, its a shame we could not find more common ground.
January 19, 2012 at 9:44 am |
Hi again , and sorry for being a bit rude in my previous comment.
there are 2 points I want to mention , that unlike judism that consider jews an ethinical group , Islam isn’t about ethinity , muslims form many nations , and many nations converted to Islam , I was refering to Palestinians as the descenders from Cananites , and I dont ignore the fact that there are christian Palestinians , atheists , agnostic , and samiratians.
my other point is , I know the religious prespective when a jew look to Islam , it’s the same we muslims look to Bahaism as example , but in the same time I know we all pray for the same god , you may call him YHWH or Elohim or Allah or God etc….. so yeah I agree with you that the one and only God created adam and eve that all human beings came from including you and me , and the article writer -which I wonder why didnt she comment here so far-
as for holy sites , we may disagree , Alaqsa mosque isn’t mount temple , it is a mosque.
January 20, 2012 at 4:19 pm |
I was rude too – apologies. I have taken all your points on board. Take care
March 20, 2012 at 11:31 pm |
If Palestinians would just STOP killing Jews. Why can’t they stop?
March 4, 2013 at 12:37 am |
It’s an remarkable article in support of all the web users; they
will take advantage from it I am sure.